Thursday, April 19, 2012

Conversations with a Liberal

So the other day I responded to a friend's Facebook post, and then to one of her friend's posting.  Normally I don't respond to be people I don't know, but come on... I couldn't help myself with logic like this!!  And quite frankly, sometimes talking to the someone of the left is entertaining.  This "liberal" states his political views on his Facebook page as being "Far Left".

I have taken out names, swears, and the Lord's name when used in vain.  It's a long read, kind of slow in the beginning, but you'll love his logic!

Friend’s Status Update
Job interview Monday. I have to skip school for it but hopefully it'll be worth it! Teller job at MAJOR BANK.

Liberal Good <gosh>, banks.
Friend Banks are good jobs. Good money.
Liberal I'd rather work for Wal*Mart or mcDonalds, at least they make sense         
Friend They don't pay as well, and thats a lot more physical for a pregnant chick to do. Too much standing and walking and lifting (in Walmarts case for sure).           
Friend But if you've got anything better, I'm open to lots of things. I just need a job.         
Liberal Well COMPANY A is almost always hiring, though tbh I don't really know any places or have any connections down there with jobs. I just don't like banks. At all. And would rather work for a company that has been more vehemently victimized on strict principle
Me Good luck! I hope it goes well!
Friend COMPANY A called me for a job like 10 times. I would work there, but they aren't flexible around my school schedule. I would have to drop out, or switch to night classes which would put me getting home at just about midnight. That is just a little too late for me, especially considering I would be working all day then at school all night- I wouldn't have time to clean the house, see my 2 year old, make meals, etc etc. I also am pregnant so I pass out around 10pm- normally I am more of a night owl but you get SO tired when youre pregnant! I'm going to go there if nothing comes up when I graduate, but until then it just isn't that great of an option I'm afraid =/ Anything else? I've been looking for a bank job because I have 6 years of cash handling experience, and there is a lot of room for promotions and such in a bank. My friend started getting $14 an hour after only a few months at a bank.
Liberal Try getting a job at a Credit Union, or a bank that isn't Wells Fargo or Bank of America             
Me Normally I don't respond to people I don't know on someone's page, but seriously? For someone so against big business, it looks like you sure like a lot of things made in China (according to what I can see on your profile). How about supporting American workers where the money is made here and spent here.  
Liberal It's not that I hate big business, it's that I hate big banks, because all they are is legalized thievery.
Other Sane Person My aunt works for Chase. She's not a thief. :/  
Liberal ‎"Guilt by association"       
Liberal The idea that banks can charge you to use your own money makes absolutely no sense, not to mention the fact that they're at this point necessary to make a living in this country as you either deal with a bank of your choice or you have to deal with ADP style pay. What happened to the days of getting a check? What happened to the days when your money was your money and you could spend it without being charged for it?          
Other Sane Person So go open a bank and run it the way you think banks should be run.
Me I'm not a huge fan of astronomical profits for big business, especially if they don't take care of their employees in terms of paying fair and benefits.  What you're saying doesn't even make sense. First, most people can get an account without any kind of fee- I have a no fee account. Secondly, you pay a fee for a service they are providing, which is safeguarding your money and providing you with an easy way to access it via ATMs and debit cards.
Me Nothing is free. 
Liberal It's more so that you're basically required to have a bank now that bothers me more than anything, why should anyone be able to tell me what I need to do with my money?
Other Sane Person And what if Friend DOES get a job with a big bank? Is she supposed to be "guilty by association" too?    
Liberal On top of that I have been charged for something the bank did, without my permission, to my account. I have had a bank steal money from me on a month to month basis- and almost charge me for overdrawing my account too!        
Me You don't have to have a bank, there are credit unions, paypal, prepaid cards. That's not a banking problem- that's a technology issue. We're moving in the direction of technology and convenience- banks are simply adapting to stay relevant.
Other Sane Person I'm sorry, I know this is a serious debate, but you're going to have to explain to me how a bank "almost charges" something. Either it charges or it doesn't. There's no almost.
Liberal I use Credit Unions exclusively after that fiasco I had with Bank of America, but not all credit unions are good- for a fact I know my mom banks with Credit Union who charges her something like a dollar every time she runs her card as Debit, which makes absolutely no sense. On top of that it bothers me that you need to have something similar to a bank (ala Credit Union or ADP pay system) to be able to receive payment from most jobs, a paper check should be just fine.
Liberal How a bank "almost" charged was I only had somewhere along the lines of like 8.50 in my account at the time, that I was going to use for food until I got paid in like two days. They charged me 8 dollars randomly, which had I used my card to purchase something before that they would've charged me the overdraft fee. Not to mention they had never mentioned anything about a monthly fee as long as I had direct deposit 
Me When she uses her card, is she not using a service someone is providing? Do the lines not have to be paid for and the card readers, and the employees who keep the service up and running? Having worked for a credit merchant company in the past, I can tell you, it costs money to maintain things.
Secondly- how is a job requiring a direct deposit (which I will agree is common nowadays) the bank's fault? That's an issue for the job and your HR group. If you don't like it, talk to your job.  
Liberal It is partly the jobs fault for requiring that, but it's also a bank issue because if banks never initiated the idea of direct deposit then jobs would never see it and think it's the way of the future.      
Me That is the worst argument I've ever heard. So it's the fault of the bank for initiating something that millions of people like and makes their life easier and more convenient and then offering that service to their customers? What an awful company for trying to make their customer's lives easier! Just tragic!  I have a feeling we'll never agree on this. I'm probably the epitome of a person you don't like- I'm pro life, Republican, in favor of the Tea Party concept, and religious. But it seems like your argument is terribly flawed.          
Other Sane Person ‎... So it's the big evil banks fault for suggesting something that will make our life easier? Yeah, I'm out. I just can't read anymore of this.
Liberal How does direct deposit make life easier?
Liberal If I didn't have to have a bank for direct deposit, they wouldn't be able to charge me fees for letting me use my money and therefore I'd be able to, well, use my money for things I want to use it for. 
Me Seriously?? Okay, fine, I'll play along. When I got a paper check, I had to take a long lunch in order to get to the bank in time to deposit it. Actually, at that time I was with a credit union who had even shorter hours than a bank. Often I was late from lunch. Then I had to wait three days for the thing to clear, meaning I didn't have money on time to pay my bills. With direct deposit, the money is in the bank and ready to use first thing in the morning. I could take a leisurely lunch, and not worry about paying my bills in time.  Again, find an account that doesn't charge you fees. I'm sure that $8 fee is over the top- so find one that doesn't have a fee. Every bank I've ever banked with offered a no fee account. Every single one.       
Liberal I agree, I've refused to bank with any bank that charges me to use my money since that incident, and I've promptly advised all friends or family members to stop banking with them as well. On top of that, what type of bank do you use that doesn't instantly clear payroll checks? Oh, and who ever said you would deposit the check into the bank?   
Me So instead I have to go directly to the bank the check is drawn on and cash my check? And without a bank, I have to get money orders for things like my mortgage and pay convenience fees for paying my utilities in person. Yes, that's MUCH more convenient.            
Me I can't chat anymore, I have to get my kid ready for bed... but this has been an interesting discussion. Sorry to take your page up Friend! Good luck- I'll send job vibes your way.
Friend I had at interview at a credit union, but it was in TOWN 40 min 1 way, plus a toll every day. Couldn't do it. They weren't hiring for the ANOTHER TOWN branch.
Liberal Wait they charge you fees...to pay your bills....in cash?        
Liberal What a <messed> up world we live in, good <gosh>.
Friend Also I love my direct deposit. I don't always have time to go to the bank. Sometimes I need to use $ from my account before I can deposit the check, especially for gas. Can't drive all the way from work to the bank with no gas. And I have to have a card for bills and gas, I don't use cash for those things. I get gas at Sams which only takes cards, so I can't just pay cash for it. Also, I can't pay my electric or my car insurance in cash, or they do charge me more. My electric automatically withdraws every month- my other option is cash, with a $600 deposit.
Liberal Good <gosh>         
Liberal What a world what a world
Liberal And imagine, if people actually cared, if people actually wanted to help other people how much better this place would be? But no you have people wanting to eliminate freedom of choice, who want to hoard money in the name of the American Dream.     
Friend Most of my bills I have to have checks for as well, which require a bank account. You can't just stick cash in an envelope and mail it. You would have to go get a money order or a check, which would require a bank or amscot or something. Its 500xs easier to direct deposit and pay online the morning my check deposits without having to go anywhere to get or use my money.    
Liberal I guess I just don't understand this world. I'm moving to Europe
Friend I would love to move to Europe. A lot of their countries have diminishing populations, which mean they don't have enough workers and the jobs are good. But it's just too far away from family. I couldn't do it.
Liberal It's not far enough away from some of my family

No comments:

Post a Comment